![]() Spending two mana just to cycle this thing always feels demoralizing, especially given that the decks you’re doing that against are usually aggressive and would love you to take a turn off just to spin your wheels.Īn effect like that can be fine if the ceiling of the card is something really good, but putting the kibosh on searching for a turn ain’t it. The floor of the card is a two-mana cantrip, which are otherwise terrible in Modern. In short, the limited one-turn window of “can’t search” just doesn’t do enough to justify its inclusion. SoD might be one of the most overrated cards in Modern, but it’s the pet card of a lot of players so it keeps getting brought up as a “hidden gem” because people get tunnel vision on the text “draw a card.” That was a cheeky and roundabout way of saying that Shadow of Doubt seems great in theory, but it’s always clunky and awkward in practice. Jeez, pal, if you’re taking it this literally, you need to lighten up. Unlike Removal spells, counter-spells, combo-pieces and top-end cards, which never gets stuck in players' hands, and would all be bad if they did. Guess you shouldn't play a card that might improve your win-rate in most match-ups because, ghost quarter, (a card that is a 1-of in 20% of decks) has the potential to make it stuck in hand. Goes to show that SoD is actually worse when playing against cards that are good against it! What a revelation, never thought of that. Good for you, you played around a card in their deck and punished them for it. If you refuse to tap out in order play around SoD and they do have it, unlikely as it is. Is SoD bad when your opponent has an active ghost quarter? It's certainly bad to cycle at that point, but it can still be decent to great when they themselves go to search. What else is going on? You could be you beating down with creatures. Never seen a control player with mana open), making sure you're never tapping in out because you're obsessed with playing around a card your opponent might have a single copy of in their entire deck. I mean stuck on a ghost quarter that you're forcing yourself to keep open because you're guessing your opponent has SoD in hand, based on them keeping mana open, (Good read btw. If it's good enough though, only testing can show. I'm in line with OP, Shadow of Doubt is as good as never before. That is 6 popular decks where the card does have a significant upside beyond the previously "just" stifling a fetchland. ![]() With Urza (10-11 Fetches and Mystical Sanctuary as target, 3 Whir of Invention), Titan (4 pacts, 4 titans, 4 tolaria west), Yawgmoth Combo (4 Evolution, 4 Chord, 4 Fetchlands), Devoted Combo (4 Devastation, 4 Eladamri's Call, 8 fetches), Stoneblade (4 Stoneforge, 8 Fetchlands with sanctuary, 3 Field of Ruins) and Tron (4 Expedition Map, 4 Sylvan Scrying, 1 Sanctum of Ugin) there are not only more tutors than ever before, but a lot of them are also quite crucial for the gameplan. The likelyhood of having impact increased. On overall usefulness it Censor is less narrow, i'll give you that and I see that just evaluating the upside is a common problem at card evaluation, but there's something fundamentally different going at the moment: Deck Primers Top Tier Thursday Archive Deck-Specific Subreddits Try to do some metagame testing to get a feel for your deck so you can talk about it better. People are not here to critique the brew you slapped together with zero thought. Please, make sure you include a description of what your deck is, what it intends to do, and specific questions that stimulate conversation. When posting deck lists, it is generally preferred that you link to a deck building site such as or something similar. It can be as simple as typing your query into google, along with the word Reddit, to see if your question has been asked before. Please do not try and sell cards or decks within this subreddit.Īll we ask is that before you post, do some research yourself to try to find the answer to your query. Single questions about cards/money/selling advice should be asked in the stickied threads posted every Mo/We/Fr.This subreddit is for players of any level of experience to discuss any topics regarding the Modern format, whether it is decks that pro's have been winning with, metagame discussion, card discussion, or home brews. "Buyer beware" posts require submitting proof with identifying info removed. SCD, Video and card photo posts must include a brief summary. ![]() No Low Effort Posts: If you are requesting research, or the answer to your question can be found through public knowledge, find it yourself and post it. No spam, flaming, brigading, harassing.Īll posts must be financially related / No counterfeit authentication requests. Friday - Things to look out for this weekend!įollow Redditiquette.Wednesday - Weekly Ask MTGFinance Anything.Monday - Weekend Wrapup! What was real and what was a trap.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |